The Western Himalaya harbours distinctive and rich mountain mammal assemblages, yet the persistence of species may conceal underlying ecological decline. We propose the concept of deceptive diversity, describing the period during which extinction debt accumulates but remains largely undetected as species continue to persist. By integrating global change, extinction debt, and long-term evidence from the Western Himalaya, this study demonstrates how species persistence can conceal hidden biodiversity erosion and provides a framework for identifying populations at risk before local extirpations occur, which is relevant to other important mountain biodiversity hotspots globally.